TL;DR:
Severance is taxed like your usual pay. The Federal withholding usually takes out 22 percent right away. California takes another 6.6 percent, and payroll taxes eat up another 7.65 percent. These withholding rates are just what gets taken out at first, not your final tax bill. You can sometimes talk to your boss about when or how you get paid.
Your severance deal might say $20,000, but your bank will show a lower number.
Severance pay taxes are the reason. Many people only find out when the money is already there.
Nobody really tells you what will get taken out. Not the papers you sign, not your boss.
You can’t dodge these taxes. But you do have some say about when you get taxed and how you get your money. Here’s what happens to your check, and what you should think about before you agree to anything.
1. Does the IRS Tax Severance Pay?
Yes, severance pay is taxed just like your regular paycheck.
Severance pay taxes come in two layers. First, there’s income tax from the government and, if you live in California, from the state too. Then payroll taxes take more.
People sometimes wonder if these taxes are even fair. In 2014, the Supreme Court made it clear in United States v. Quality Stores (2014). Severance pay is counted as wages, so payroll taxes apply. This means Social Security takes 6.2 percent and Medicare takes 1.45 percent. Together, that’s 7.65 percent of your check, gone before you see it.
2. How Is Severance Taxed on Your Paycheck?
IRS Publication 15 lets employers withhold federal income tax on severance at a flat 22% when they pay it separately from regular wages. There is a special rule if your extra pay is over one million dollars in a year. In that case, the government takes out 37 percent instead.
If your boss puts your severance into your normal paycheck, there is a different formula.
Here’s the curveball: that 22% isn’t your severance tax rate. It’s a down payment.
You find out your true tax bill when you file your taxes. If your income lands in a lower bracket, you get a refund. If it lands in a higher bracket, you owe the difference.
3. What Does California Take Out of Your Severance?
California has its own flat tax for severance. Most of the time, your boss takes out 6.6 percent, because that’s what the Employment Development Department (EDD) says to do. If you get a bonus or stock, the state gets 10.23 percent.
Severance usually falls in the first group. This severance withholding tax stacks on top of the federal amount.
Let’s see how this looks with a $20,000 severance check.
- The federal government takes 22%: $4,400
- California withholding at 6.6%: $1,320
- Payroll taxes at 7.65%: $1,530
Withholding takes about $7,250. You take home about $12,750.
At Severance Review Lawyer, we check whether the number in your agreement is gross or net. Most are gross, which means your take-home will be smaller than the big number you see at first.
4. Does the Way You Get Paid Change Your Tax Bill?
Yes. Two things make a big difference. You can get all your money at once, or you can get it in smaller payments. The year you get paid also matters a lot.
If you get a big lump sum, your boss usually takes out the flat tax rate. If you get paid little by little, your boss follows your W-4, like with a normal paycheck.
Timing can have a huge impact on your severance pay taxes. If you get your check in December, it gets added to your whole year’s income. That can push your taxes up. If you get paid in January, you might make less money that year, so your tax bill could be smaller. Sometimes waiting just a few weeks can save you cash.
5. Can You Lower Your Tax Bill Through Negotiation?
You can’t talk your way out of the tax on severance payments. But you can ask for different ways to get your money. The timing and setup are where you have some power.
- A January payment date: It helps to ask for your severance in January, especially if you lost your job right before the new year.
- Installments across two tax years: You might also want your money spread out over two years. That way, the tax hit isn’t all at once.
- Clear gross language: Your agreement should state the gross amount and say “less applicable withholdings.”
- A written payment schedule: Ask for a written payment schedule, too. A promise from HR that isn’t in writing doesn’t mean much.
At Severance Review Lawyer, we negotiate payment timing and structure with your employer alongside the dollar amount. For your specific return, a tax professional should run your numbers.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does severance get taxed more than my regular pay?
No, it doesn’t. The government just takes out more upfront, but when you do your taxes, it all gets counted the same as your normal paycheck.
If my job takes out too much tax, can I get some back?
Yes, you can. If they took out more than you really owe, you get that money back when you file your taxes.
Does severance money count for Social Security and Medicare?
Yes, it does. The government treats severance like normal pay, so they take out that 7.65 percent for those taxes.
Can I pick how much tax comes out of my severance?
No, your boss decides how much to take out. You can change your W-4 for your regular paychecks, but the final numbers get sorted out when you do your taxes.
If my severance comes in January, do I still owe tax?
Yes, you do. It counts as income for that year, so when you get the check matters for your taxes.
Can I ask for my severance to be paid a certain way?
Yes, you can. Many employers will work with you on things like timing and how they send the money. Sometimes all you have to do is ask.
Don’t Sign Before You Know What You’ll Get
The number in your agreement is not the number you’ll see in your bank account.
Always check how much money you’ll really take home while you can still make changes.
Want help figuring it out?
Key Takeaways
- Severance pay is taxed. The government, the state, and payroll taxes all take a piece.
- Most bosses take out 22 percent for federal taxes. California takes out another 6.6 percent, and payroll taxes cut 7.65 percent more.
- That 22 percent is just what gets taken out at first. It’s not your final tax bill. After you file your taxes, you might get some money back, or you might have to pay more.
- When you get your severance check, it matters, too. Getting paid in January, or in smaller payments, can sometimes keep you in a lower tax bracket.
- You can’t change the tax rules, but you can ask for the money in a way that helps you out.
